Home » Public Perceptions of Gender Bias in the Decisions of Female State Court Judges

Public Perceptions of Gender Bias in the Decisions of Female State Court Judges

PDF · Michael P. Fix & Gbemende E. Johnson · Nov-28-2017 · 70 Vand. L. Rev. 1845 (2017)

Public Perceptions of Gender Bias in the Decisions of Female State Court Judges

ABSTRACT

How are women on the bench, and their decisions, perceived by the public? Many scholars find that gender influences the voting behavior of judges and the assessment of judges by state judicial systems and the American Bar Association. However, few scholars have examined how judge gender affects the way in which the public responds to judicial outcomes. Does the public perceive the decisions of female state court judges as being “biased” by their gender identity, particularly in cases involving reproductive rights/family law? Also, does the public view female judges on state courts as more likely to rely on ideology when ruling in cases? Using a survey experiment that varies judge gender in a state child custody case, we examine whether respondents exhibit less support for judicial decisions authored by female state court judges. Additionally, we test whether respondents are more likely to perceive the decisions of female state court judges as ideologically biased or as a product of gender influences (as compared to male judges). Finally, we assess whether these effects are conditional on or exacerbated by respondent characteristics such as gender, race, and religiosity. The influence of gender on public response to state court decisions has important implications for our understanding of why certain court decisions find public support and acceptance.

AUTHORS

Michael P. Fix

Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, Georgia State University

Gbemende E. Johnson

Assistant Professor, Department of Government, Hamilton College



Comments are closed.